At an engagement party on Saturday:
Me: Wow, she's wearing a My Little Pony T-shirt!
T. (turns to look): Oh! It's Galaxy!

Cue stunned silence, followed by incredulous laughter.

Given that he had complimented the host's (yes, male) long eyelashes earlier, it would seem that I have a knack for going out with guys who are really in touch with their feminine side.

(Updated) Later on, after writing this post:
Me: By the way, it was Heathwitch on the T-shirt, not Galaxy.
T.: Told you I could have been wrong. Galaxy has a horn, right?
Me: ... (sends link to picture of Galaxy over)
T.: Look, you can see the tiny baby unicorn horn on her head.
Me: Are you sure you're not gay?

And just for fun, play "Porn Star or My Little Pony?"

I got 3 out of 12. What were those cartoon writers thinking?